The Perfect Speech for an Imperfect Union

English: A screengrab from President Barack Ob...

A screengrab from President Barack Obama’s first White House news conference. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

By David Swerdlick

Though, like so many others, I was moved by President Barack Obama’s insightful remarks at Friday’s White House press briefing, I stand by my view that the president would have been better served in the long run if he’d let his original comments on the George Zimmerman verdict stand on their own.

Because as I wrote Monday, as “the most visible — and powerful — black man in the world,” Obama “ought to speak out — and has spoken out — in support of Trayvon Martin’s family,” even though, for better or worse, because he’s the president, “it’s also his job to represent the American system, with all its attendant flaws.”

And though I don’t in any way think that what he said Friday disrespected the verdict or the jury that rendered it, if he had asked me, I would still have advised him to move on and let the rest of us continue the debate that’s taking place on cable news and Twitter as well as in the halls of Congress and living rooms.

It had been edifying — to me, anyway — that President Obama had stayed above all the fray.

But since he did choose to speak on America’s relationship with a gunned-down black teenager whom the president mournfully described as a young man who “could have been me 35 years ago,” the reflection Obama offered reminded me of what Wall Street Journal columnist and former Ronald Reagan speechwriter Peggy Noonan said about Obama’s “A More Perfect Union” speech back in 2008: that then-Sen. Obama’s words were “as honest a speech as one in his position could give within the limits imposed by politics.”

And you could say the same about his eloquent valediction for the late Trayvon Martin.

Given his tears after Newtown, Conn., and his heartbreaking State of the Union remembrance that slain Chicago teenager Hadiya Pendleton was “a majorette” who “loved Fig Newtons and lip gloss,” it seems pretty clear that it’s this kind of stuff that gets to him as a father.

t would have been tough for Obama to give a more balanced, sober or hopeful exposition of where we should go from here. And while acknowledging the limits of a president, or government, to bring an immediate sense of healing or justice to the tragedy, Obama did offer a template for thinking constructively about its aftermath. No matter what his detractors say — and they’ll say plenty — it’s hard to have heard the speech and not feel that just like the rest of us, even the president is woeful that he can’t do more.

Read More Obama Statement on Zimmerman Verdict: He Chose His Words Well.

About The Soul Brother

An observer to the world. I have a unique view of the world and want to share it. It's all in love from the people of the "blues". Love, Knowledge, and Sharing amongst all is the first steps towards solving all the problems amongst humanity.
This entry was posted in News from the Soul Brother and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s